And can you describe what you think is wrong with that article? Does it make you question whether those 60+ dead were unrelated to the Israeli attack??
If that’s the case then it’s just an issue of the Guardian being written for smarter people
You gave a link accusing them of quoting Israeli officials
You don’t seem to be able to back up your accusation that they have been avoiding to use the word ‘killed’. So why make it?
The Guardian is not misinforming their readers about what’s happening in Gaza.
The way you’re talking about this is telling me that you’re too far gone to look at these things objectively
Do you have any examples of the Guardian dancing around the word ‘killed’? The fact you have to resort to their reporting on unrelated issues seems to suggest that’s not really the case
Do you have anything to back this up? I’ve never felt The Guardian was using euphemisms
Good, then we both agree the source doesn’t support the “hundreds of thousands murdered in Poland” claim.
Lol, if you want to try and move the goalposts from my “murdered Poles” to your “in Poland”, I can only say that’s just childish. Do you think it’s better if they died in Russia?
No, I really cannot pretend knowing more about defeating fascism in Europe that the nation which ultimately defeated fascism, at the IMMENSE cost of 25 million lives in the struggle against Nazism.
Hexbear incoming. “They helped defeat the nazis so the bottom line is we can’t criticize them”.
Imagine how we would look at the US if they had decided it was more profitable to just team up with the nazis instead
That’s a book on migrations and deportations, not a book on casualties, it doesn’t seem to support a claim of “hundreds of thousands murdered” which you made in your previous comment, could you please elaborate?
Again, you’re conflating murdered with deported
It most certainly includes direct casualty numbers as well, for Poland and many other conflicts.
Great, please name one of them that doesn’t imply complete occupation of Poland by Nazis
I just can’t envision an alternative reality
Well, I think that’s the main issue here. Siding with the nazis, attacking Poland in the rear when they were fighting the nazis, committing horrible crimes against the Polish population and POWs … You really, really cannot imagine not having to do even one of those
I get that the book you want me to read claims, like the previous poster, that the only option Russia had was to secretly team up with the nazis and attack the Poles from the rear
But my question is not so much to repeat that but to support it with arguments
Could you paraphrase the parts of the book that would be relevant?
please tell me what was the alternative to Soviet occupation in Eastern Poland, once Poland rejected a mutual defense agreement against Nazis with the Soviets
There were several alternatives, actually. But most of them would start with Russia not attacking them in the rear after they moved their troops west to fight off the nazis
can you provide a source for that? I know about the Katyn massacre and about other events in which Nazi collaborators/Bourgeois Polish nationalists were killed (as well as some innocent civilians), but AFAIK the numbers don’t go that high
Yeah sure, here’s one that estimates between 250k and 1.5m (but which I believe also includes post-war)
But I presume that if you’re the type that already convinced themselves that all these murdered Poles “must have deserved it” in one way or another, then that number probably couldn’t be high enough anyway
Not to defend the flawed comparison with Trump’s treason, but that’s a very useless take on the M-R pact…
Stalin could have
I think all of these alternatives would have been more desirable than, well, actively teaming up with the nazis
edit: list layout
The article claims the exact opposite, ie. that the mentioned amount of bombs was largely dropped on targets within Gaza.
The term ‘Gaza envelope’ does not appear once and looks like a fabrication
With Hamas seemingly agreeing to most of Israel’s terms, I think he gave them a hard ‘last chance’ in order to force it.
You sound like a caricature account ran by the Mossad to discredit pro-Palestinian posters